Too Early to start using estrus????????
10-21-2009, 09:30 AM
#1
Spike
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: Michigan
Posts: 8
Too Early to start using estrus????????
Well, here we are! it's October 21st and I'm sure all of us hunters are anticipating the rut. Is anyone in the midwest using estrus yet? If so, with good or poor results? I would like to start using in the next couple of days but have not seen to much rut type activity to this point. What is your opinion? Would I do more harm than good? Should I be waiting a week or more?
10-21-2009, 09:53 AM
#2
Fork Horn
Join Date: Oct 2005
Posts: 222
There is no simple answer to your question. There are two schools of thought on this particular topic.
1. Bucks are ready to mate pretty much anytime so using estrus shouldn't hurt anything. (I've had deer come up in the beginning of October to estrus both bucks and does first buck I ever shot with a bow caming running straight to the smell after I bleated.)
2. Even though bucks are ready to mate at anytime the smell of estrus in the woods is out of place and could spook the deer. (It could have been another smell that spooked the deer but he was right in the area where the scent would be blowing on him but shouldn't have been in a spot that my human scent would have hit him this has happened twice)
Here is my opinion I've tried both and I've gotten both results. So try it if it works for you then go with it. If it doesn't then don't use it again until the rut is in full swing.
1. Bucks are ready to mate pretty much anytime so using estrus shouldn't hurt anything. (I've had deer come up in the beginning of October to estrus both bucks and does first buck I ever shot with a bow caming running straight to the smell after I bleated.)
2. Even though bucks are ready to mate at anytime the smell of estrus in the woods is out of place and could spook the deer. (It could have been another smell that spooked the deer but he was right in the area where the scent would be blowing on him but shouldn't have been in a spot that my human scent would have hit him this has happened twice)
Here is my opinion I've tried both and I've gotten both results. So try it if it works for you then go with it. If it doesn't then don't use it again until the rut is in full swing.
10-21-2009, 10:05 AM
#3
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: New Hampshire
Posts: 3,406
There is no simple answer to your question. There are two schools of thought on this particular topic.
1. Bucks are ready to mate pretty much anytime so using estrus shouldn't hurt anything. (I've had deer come up in the beginning of October to estrus both bucks and does first buck I ever shot with a bow caming running straight to the smell after I bleated.)
2. Even though bucks are ready to mate at anytime the smell of estrus in the woods is out of place and could spook the deer. (It could have been another smell that spooked the deer but he was right in the area where the scent would be blowing on him but shouldn't have been in a spot that my human scent would have hit him this has happened twice)
Here is my opinion I've tried both and I've gotten both results. So try it if it works for you then go with it. If it doesn't then don't use it again until the rut is in full swing.
1. Bucks are ready to mate pretty much anytime so using estrus shouldn't hurt anything. (I've had deer come up in the beginning of October to estrus both bucks and does first buck I ever shot with a bow caming running straight to the smell after I bleated.)
2. Even though bucks are ready to mate at anytime the smell of estrus in the woods is out of place and could spook the deer. (It could have been another smell that spooked the deer but he was right in the area where the scent would be blowing on him but shouldn't have been in a spot that my human scent would have hit him this has happened twice)
Here is my opinion I've tried both and I've gotten both results. So try it if it works for you then go with it. If it doesn't then don't use it again until the rut is in full swing.
