What are the 5 biggest hunting myths?
#11
Fork Horn
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Central Iowa
Posts: 234
RE: What are the 5 biggest hunting myths?
Myth- Human urine drives away deer. (It is actually an attractant)
Myth- Deer can locate you if you make a brief sound. (In truth, deer have to focus their hearing, brief quick sounds, while heard by deer, do not give your location away. Deer have independently moving ears and they have to "focus" their hearing. This is why deer will often look in the wrong direction at a gun shot or other brief noise.)
Human's hearing, while not as sharp as a deer, is always in focus. A human can hear a little pop and immediately know where it came from.
Bob
Myth- Deer can locate you if you make a brief sound. (In truth, deer have to focus their hearing, brief quick sounds, while heard by deer, do not give your location away. Deer have independently moving ears and they have to "focus" their hearing. This is why deer will often look in the wrong direction at a gun shot or other brief noise.)
Human's hearing, while not as sharp as a deer, is always in focus. A human can hear a little pop and immediately know where it came from.
Bob
#12
RE: What are the 5 biggest hunting myths?
1. Deer and elk see in black and white. Scientific research, instigated by me, and done by Vision Scientist Dr. Jayy Neitz, and Deer hIologist and Researcher Dr. Larry Marchinton, shoed that whitetails see the colors blue and yellow very well, but not red and green.
2. Peak breeding of whitetail deer occurs during the full moon. Scientific resaerc, condudted by the Minnesota DNR, and myself, showed that peak breeding of whitetails generally occurs within about the same 10 day period every year, regardless of the phase of the moon. This study was later backed up by Dr. Karl Miller at the U of GA, who used the breeding dates of over 2500+ deer.
3. Whitetail does use an "estrus call". No such call has ever been recorded by, nontheless mentioned by, whitetail researchers.
4. Cow elk use an "estrus call". After 4 years of research on captive elk, and seeing over 20 cows get bred, I never heard any of them make any sound (that could be associated with breeding) within 20 minutes of getting bred. A bull determines if a cow is in estrus by smelling the area where the cow was laying down, or by smelling the cow itself.
5. Female mallards make a chuckling sound, often referred to as the "feeding chuckle", that is used by ducks to get other ducks to come and feed with them. Research by Dr. Paul Johansgard showed that this call is an "incitement call". The hen is using this call to incite her mate to attack any other drake that is tyring to "cozy up to her".
2. Peak breeding of whitetail deer occurs during the full moon. Scientific resaerc, condudted by the Minnesota DNR, and myself, showed that peak breeding of whitetails generally occurs within about the same 10 day period every year, regardless of the phase of the moon. This study was later backed up by Dr. Karl Miller at the U of GA, who used the breeding dates of over 2500+ deer.
3. Whitetail does use an "estrus call". No such call has ever been recorded by, nontheless mentioned by, whitetail researchers.
4. Cow elk use an "estrus call". After 4 years of research on captive elk, and seeing over 20 cows get bred, I never heard any of them make any sound (that could be associated with breeding) within 20 minutes of getting bred. A bull determines if a cow is in estrus by smelling the area where the cow was laying down, or by smelling the cow itself.
5. Female mallards make a chuckling sound, often referred to as the "feeding chuckle", that is used by ducks to get other ducks to come and feed with them. Research by Dr. Paul Johansgard showed that this call is an "incitement call". The hen is using this call to incite her mate to attack any other drake that is tyring to "cozy up to her".
#13
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Aug 2007
Posts: 1,862
RE: What are the 5 biggest hunting myths?
One of the biggest myths is that Quality Deer Management was established to benefit a deer population. Nothing but a bunch of BS!! It was created by trophy hunters in hope that it might help grow even bigger bucks for them to shoot, period! Things like planting food plots and killing only mature bucks has absolutely NOTHING to do with the natural balance of things.
#14
RE: What are the 5 biggest hunting myths?
Moon phase, does it really affect movement - who cares!
wind over 20 mph, I don't like my stand to turn into an amusement ride!
heavy rain, the kind where it rolls down your crack!
I've never had ANY luck with these...
So it's a myth that you can ACTUALLY get a deer when you employ hunting during these activities.
wind over 20 mph, I don't like my stand to turn into an amusement ride!
heavy rain, the kind where it rolls down your crack!
I've never had ANY luck with these...
So it's a myth that you can ACTUALLY get a deer when you employ hunting during these activities.
#15
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Ohio,mid
Posts: 1,275
RE: What are the 5 biggest hunting myths?
1. if you aim/lead at the tip of a running deers nose you will hit it in the heart,
2. The guys on tv are the best hunters in the world
3. That a heavy caliber is overkill for deer
4. That you don't have to eat a peice of the heart or get marked w/ blood on your forehead on your first kill!! (for my nephew)
5. You can't stalk hunt deer.
2. The guys on tv are the best hunters in the world
3. That a heavy caliber is overkill for deer
4. That you don't have to eat a peice of the heart or get marked w/ blood on your forehead on your first kill!! (for my nephew)
5. You can't stalk hunt deer.
#16
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Adirondacks
Posts: 1,305
RE: What are the 5 biggest hunting myths?
1.Big cals/high energy kill quicker than smaller rounds.
2.The importance of wearing camo.
3.Compounds are superior to trad bows.
4.Open sighted lever action rifles are faster for follow up shots than scoped bolt actions.
5.Obama does not want our guns.Should have listed this myth number one !!!
2.The importance of wearing camo.
3.Compounds are superior to trad bows.
4.Open sighted lever action rifles are faster for follow up shots than scoped bolt actions.
5.Obama does not want our guns.Should have listed this myth number one !!!
#17
Typical Buck
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Colorado
Posts: 797
RE: What are the 5 biggest hunting myths?
1. Firepower replaces shot placement
2. Spending thousands of dollars on equipment will make you a better hunter
3. Animals won't be out in bad weather
4. Bugling from a ATV is the fastest way to find a bull elk
5. If I look like a bush and smell like a bush the game won't see the bush get up and move.
2. Spending thousands of dollars on equipment will make you a better hunter
3. Animals won't be out in bad weather
4. Bugling from a ATV is the fastest way to find a bull elk
5. If I look like a bush and smell like a bush the game won't see the bush get up and move.
#19
RE: What are the 5 biggest hunting myths?
ORIGINAL: Bernie P.
1.Big cals/high energy kill quicker than smaller rounds.
2.The importance of wearing camo.
3.Compounds are superior to trad bows.
4.Open sighted lever action rifles are faster for follow up shots than scoped bolt actions.
5.Obama does not want our guns.Should have listed this myth number one !!!
1.Big cals/high energy kill quicker than smaller rounds.
2.The importance of wearing camo.
3.Compounds are superior to trad bows.
4.Open sighted lever action rifles are faster for follow up shots than scoped bolt actions.
5.Obama does not want our guns.Should have listed this myth number one !!!
But I'm just applying common sense, so who knows....
#20
Fork Horn
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Colorado
Posts: 335
RE: What are the 5 biggest hunting myths?
- you have to "bleed" a deer by cutting it's throat when you gut it.
- you have to cut out the tarsal glands or they'll contaminate the meat.
These are two that I kept running into when I first started.
Spud
- you have to cut out the tarsal glands or they'll contaminate the meat.
These are two that I kept running into when I first started.
Spud