huntmdown2

You know it's really tough to say. I looked at the bases first and than I looked at it's legs. They look like the same deer to me, Just my thoughts.

bob d

i say they are different bucks

Arrowmaster

They are different bucks. Notice the outstretched front leg. The first pic shows more white and the second doesnt show the white on top of the front leg. Yes I know you cant see much of the inside of the leg on pic 2 but judging with the first pic shows it to be more on the inside of the 2nd pic. WOW did I say that right hehehehehehe. anyway yas get what Im trying to say...

Elkcrazy8

I would say the same buck. Look at the deers right antler. At the base of the antler there is somewhat of a half moon that is darker than the rest of the base. At the base of the deers left antler there is a small dark spot on the front at the bottom. These two patterns are on both pictures.

nebraskabuckhunter

I do beleive that it is the same buck but my eyes may be fooling me

glasgowm

Thank you all for your help and comments. I guess I'll just hope I get more pictures of him/them to show more difinitively. I'm glad to know it wasn't just me who couldn't decide. lol

Matthew

buckhunter2054

From what I see I think it's two different bucks. Like everyone has said the bases look alittle different. Plus to me it looks like the brow tines are closer together on the first picture compared to the second. Also on the second picture on the bucks right antler it looks like a another tine was trying to start out at the end of the main beam? It's hard to tell though.

springcaller

It's not the same deer. First, look at the bases, it's obvious. Second, look at the main beems, the deer on the top has a much thicker main beem. Guess it all comes down to when the pictures were taken, how much time between pictures?

Anthony T.

May be the same deer, but the bottom one looks to have more black on the face. Might be the difference in light between the 2 pics though. Just guessing, I'd say different.