carbon arrows ?
10-03-2007, 10:51 AM
#1
Typical Buck
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2006
Posts: 882
carbon arrows ?
[hr]
I broke the old bow out of mothballs 1980 browning explorer 2 ,45 to 60 lbs bow made back in 1980
The last time I hunted with the bow was 1998 then my peak weight was 60lb :The bow has a 35% let off and back then I used easton xx75 2117 shafts with 5" feathers with off-set.I am not new to bow hunting been in the sport for more then 25 years before I did hang it up.
I now find as age is creeping up I set the bow to 50lbs and still using 2117 xx75 but been interested in maybe switching to carbon arrows.
I see they are a little different then using the chart back then I was wondering if a 400 grain arrow with be my size for my set up.
The bow is a 4 wheeler all wood laminated including limbs:I just tuned the bow with the 2117 bare shaft at 15 yards and the arrow flies straight as a dime.
any help would be appreciated on arrow selection
My broad head 125 thunderhead
arrow length 30"[/align]
I broke the old bow out of mothballs 1980 browning explorer 2 ,45 to 60 lbs bow made back in 1980
The last time I hunted with the bow was 1998 then my peak weight was 60lb :The bow has a 35% let off and back then I used easton xx75 2117 shafts with 5" feathers with off-set.I am not new to bow hunting been in the sport for more then 25 years before I did hang it up.
I now find as age is creeping up I set the bow to 50lbs and still using 2117 xx75 but been interested in maybe switching to carbon arrows.
I see they are a little different then using the chart back then I was wondering if a 400 grain arrow with be my size for my set up.
The bow is a 4 wheeler all wood laminated including limbs:I just tuned the bow with the 2117 bare shaft at 15 yards and the arrow flies straight as a dime.
any help would be appreciated on arrow selection
My broad head 125 thunderhead
arrow length 30"[/align]
10-03-2007, 11:34 AM
#2
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Plum Boro, PA
Posts: 1,423
RE: carbon arrows ?
My .02...
If the bow is still in good shape andand those 2117's are shooting good for you, I'd leave well enough alone and hunt. That old bow isn't going to fling arrows out very fast even if you make the change to carbon.I'd just stay withthe heavier aluminums and hunt.
If the bow is still in good shape andand those 2117's are shooting good for you, I'd leave well enough alone and hunt. That old bow isn't going to fling arrows out very fast even if you make the change to carbon.I'd just stay withthe heavier aluminums and hunt.
10-04-2007, 09:11 AM
#6
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Feb 2003
Posts: 9,175
RE: carbon arrows ?
Not sure the extra stress of the lighter arrows on a laminated, 27 year old bow would be worth the speed gain.
10-04-2007, 01:31 PM
#7
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Middletown PA United States
Posts: 3,625
RE: carbon arrows ?
I have to agree with the others. Being that old, the limb technology wasn't what it is today. I wouldn't tell you not to shoot carbon arrows, but do your homework to find some comparable in weight to the 2117's or just maybe slightly lighter.
It's not just so simple to say "carbon or aluminum". There are carbon arrows that weigh more than aluminums of like spine and length.
Frankly, my personal opinion? If you have enough aluminums then that's what I'd shoot. Having to shoot a carbon a like weight is not going to achieve anything for you except possibly better durability. There would just not be enough speed gain to justify the cost.
And while you're at it I'd suggest a new string (Dacron or B50). I would assume, having been shooting compounds for 35 years now, that yours has steel cables. Don't worry about them, but change the string.
It's not just so simple to say "carbon or aluminum". There are carbon arrows that weigh more than aluminums of like spine and length.
Frankly, my personal opinion? If you have enough aluminums then that's what I'd shoot. Having to shoot a carbon a like weight is not going to achieve anything for you except possibly better durability. There would just not be enough speed gain to justify the cost.
And while you're at it I'd suggest a new string (Dacron or B50). I would assume, having been shooting compounds for 35 years now, that yours has steel cables. Don't worry about them, but change the string.
10-04-2007, 08:05 PM
#9
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Ohio
Posts: 7,876
RE: carbon arrows ?
Well, I say do what you want just keep the arrow weight to a minimum of 460 grns.total. The carbons would be quieter on the draw. If it was me I'd use the aluminums first. I'm cheap like that. I'd also go with a 400 spine carbon for starters.
