17 HMR or 22 Mag?
#11
RE: 17 HMR or 22 Mag?
heres a test on penetration between a .17hmr and a .22 long rifle. the .22 long rifle had more penetration than the 17 , when comparing the best of both, but more or less they are about the same.
http://www.glocktalk.com/attachment.php?s=fa4f25480558d7c13dcc7ec3aa396642& postid=3020251
http://www.glocktalk.com/attachment.php?s=fa4f25480558d7c13dcc7ec3aa396642& postid=3020251
#12
Typical Buck
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location:
Posts: 564
RE: 17 HMR or 22 Mag?
I have read that the .17 is rated for game that weighs 2 1/2 pounds or less. I have also read guys having to shoot a coon 4 times with the 17 before dropping them. Thats what I've read, anyhow
zrexpilot
but more or less they are about the same.
but more or less they are about the same.
#13
RE: 17 HMR or 22 Mag?
The .17 is a fad. it will disapear. I would never suggest taking yotes with a .17, If you hit a yote in the vitals it will run off to die a slow death, guaranteed. A.22 mag's a better choice, but I would still not reccomend it for yotes either. A dog is one tough animal, they can take much bigger bullets and still run off.
The .17 is for rabbitts at a 100 yds, thats it. it will probably be outlawed for predator hunting, mark my words.
The .17 is for rabbitts at a 100 yds, thats it. it will probably be outlawed for predator hunting, mark my words.
#14
RE: 17 HMR or 22 Mag?
The 17 will fade away. It lacks penitratoin. I do think it would be good for coon hunting at night with dogs in the river bottoms where you have VERY tall trees. Allso may be good for squirrels.
For yotes the 22mag would be a better choice.
I do not think the 17 will get outlawed, for most people do not even pick up the ypte they shoot [:@]
I beleave this should go under the want not waste not LAW and they should get a ticket.Yotes as like all fured animals are a resource that should get used not just killed and left to lay.
For yotes the 22mag would be a better choice.
I do not think the 17 will get outlawed, for most people do not even pick up the ypte they shoot [:@]
I beleave this should go under the want not waste not LAW and they should get a ticket.Yotes as like all fured animals are a resource that should get used not just killed and left to lay.