Weatherby Mk V vs Vanguard comparisms
#11
Join Date: May 2004
Location:
Posts: 454
RE: Weatherby Mk V vs Vanguard comparisms
I picked up a Vanguard many years ago chambered in 7-08 and fell in love with it. It has to be one of my best shooting rifles and of course, the 7-08 caliber is a terrific round. On the other hand, I've known 4 different folks who owned the Mk5s and everyone of them had serious problems. All 4 of them had the similar problem of walking as they heated up. Great first shot, but it wnt down hill from there. They all looked beautiful when taken out of the safe but they weren't much good for hunting with. As to the question if I'd take one for free!?! Of course I would, but I wouldn't give allot of money for one. (Mk 5 that is)
#12
RE: Weatherby Mk V vs Vanguard comparisms
I think the Mark V is over priced also as are most Weatherby's,all you are paying for is the "NAME". I have Vanguard that shoots execelent and it cost less than 1/2 of the other WBY's...[:-]
#14
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location:
Posts: 2,052
RE: Weatherby Mk V vs Vanguard comparisms
Stubbs I guess you is correct. TOLD YA my memory seldom served me correctly, reckon I had my wires crossed (my wife says I was born that way! )
And YES SACO in ME is the firm I was thinkin about but had them confused as to who built what. Either way the Howa built guns are VERY fine arms and I have owned them before and will likely own them in the future.
But have to disagree that a Mk V is a fitful POC. The guns are very good, very strong actions and the build quality is equally exceptional. As for the "walking when hot" that is more a symptom of the way they are built than an inherent problem with them. ANY rifle that shoots high velocity bullets through a very thinly contoured barrel will heat up very quickly. Add too that fact that the Deluxe models arent floated and you do have a tendancy to "walk" if you keep pulling the trigger. But realistically its not a consideration in a big game hunting gun, only for target or varmint shooters.
"...Pay for the name..."? Show me ANYTHING of reputation that you don't pay a premium for. Does it really cost Mercedes $100,000 to build a car that doesn't do anything a $50,000 Cadillac wont? Don't get me wrong guys, I am not saying the Mk V is THE supreme be all too the rifle world. But it's not the only overpriced gun on the market. A Sako is equally overpriced. And if you REALLY want to talk about overcharging, how about Blaser's or the recent 84% wholesale increase that Beretta passed too dealers in 04 on the Sauer 202, which effectively DOUBLED the price of the rifle overnight?
The price of an item is bared out by those who want to purchase them. Roy Weatherby charged as much as the market would bare for his Mk V and it made his company very profitable and his wallet fat.
Aint that the American way?
RA
And YES SACO in ME is the firm I was thinkin about but had them confused as to who built what. Either way the Howa built guns are VERY fine arms and I have owned them before and will likely own them in the future.
But have to disagree that a Mk V is a fitful POC. The guns are very good, very strong actions and the build quality is equally exceptional. As for the "walking when hot" that is more a symptom of the way they are built than an inherent problem with them. ANY rifle that shoots high velocity bullets through a very thinly contoured barrel will heat up very quickly. Add too that fact that the Deluxe models arent floated and you do have a tendancy to "walk" if you keep pulling the trigger. But realistically its not a consideration in a big game hunting gun, only for target or varmint shooters.
"...Pay for the name..."? Show me ANYTHING of reputation that you don't pay a premium for. Does it really cost Mercedes $100,000 to build a car that doesn't do anything a $50,000 Cadillac wont? Don't get me wrong guys, I am not saying the Mk V is THE supreme be all too the rifle world. But it's not the only overpriced gun on the market. A Sako is equally overpriced. And if you REALLY want to talk about overcharging, how about Blaser's or the recent 84% wholesale increase that Beretta passed too dealers in 04 on the Sauer 202, which effectively DOUBLED the price of the rifle overnight?
The price of an item is bared out by those who want to purchase them. Roy Weatherby charged as much as the market would bare for his Mk V and it made his company very profitable and his wallet fat.
Aint that the American way?
RA
#15
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: fort mcmurray alberta canada
Posts: 5,667
RE: Weatherby Mk V vs Vanguard comparisms
A Sako is equally overpriced.
#16
Join Date: May 2004
Location:
Posts: 454
RE: Weatherby Mk V vs Vanguard comparisms
ORIGINAL: RedAllison
and the build quality is equally exceptional. As for the "walking when hot" that is more a symptom of the way they are built than an inherent problem with them. ANY rifle that shoots high velocity bullets through a very thinly contoured barrel will heat up very quickly. Add too that fact that the Deluxe models arent floated and you do have a tendancy to "walk" if you keep pulling the trigger.
and the build quality is equally exceptional. As for the "walking when hot" that is more a symptom of the way they are built than an inherent problem with them. ANY rifle that shoots high velocity bullets through a very thinly contoured barrel will heat up very quickly. Add too that fact that the Deluxe models arent floated and you do have a tendancy to "walk" if you keep pulling the trigger.
I'm shooting a 'cheap old Remington' in 300RUM, so I understand the concept of barrel heating with high velocity rounds. What I don't get in my POC Remington are rounds walking literally off the paper. It will shoot pretty true, even when it's to hot to touch the barrel. My point before was, I've only ever been around 4 Mk V's, and they all did the same thing.
ORIGINAL: RedAllison But realistically its not a consideration in a big game hunting gun, only for target or varmint shooters.
I'm sorry, If I'm spending $1200-$1500 for a rifle, it's a consideration, regardless what I'm hunting.
#17
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: fort mcmurray alberta canada
Posts: 5,667
RE: Weatherby Mk V vs Vanguard comparisms
It will shoot pretty true, even when it's to hot to touch
#18
Fork Horn
Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 111
RE: Weatherby Mk V vs Vanguard comparisms
Well, my primary hunting rifle is a Weatherby Accumark in 7mm Rem. Mag. and it is topped with a Swarovsky glass.
Now, it has a semi-bull barrel and even when reasonably hot (not as hot as not being able to touch it) it still shoots 1" groups at 100 meters.
I owned several MK5's in the past and no one has ever let me down.
Overpriced? Maybe.....Good? Yes.....Reliable? For sure.....
If anybody consider a $ 500.00 Dollar rig (including scope) a realible thing, I guess they still have a lot of hunting to do and a lot of frustration to suffer when it fails in the precise moment. Remember, you only get what you pay for.....
Now, it has a semi-bull barrel and even when reasonably hot (not as hot as not being able to touch it) it still shoots 1" groups at 100 meters.
I owned several MK5's in the past and no one has ever let me down.
Overpriced? Maybe.....Good? Yes.....Reliable? For sure.....
If anybody consider a $ 500.00 Dollar rig (including scope) a realible thing, I guess they still have a lot of hunting to do and a lot of frustration to suffer when it fails in the precise moment. Remember, you only get what you pay for.....
#19
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: fort mcmurray alberta canada
Posts: 5,667
RE: Weatherby Mk V vs Vanguard comparisms
If anybody consider a $ 500.00 Dollar rig (including scope) a realible thing, I guess they still have a lot of hunting to do and a lot of frustration to suffer when it fails in the precise moment. Remember, you only get what you pay for.....
#20
Giant Nontypical
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location:
Posts: 6,471
RE: Weatherby Mk V vs Vanguard comparisms
If anybody consider a $ 500.00 Dollar rig (including scope) a realible thing, I guess they still have a lot of hunting to do and a lot of frustration to suffer when it fails in the precise moment. Remember, you only get what you pay for.....