hdsanders

3 1/2 year old is the one I would take.

RobinHood36

A

silentassassin

A

RiverBottomBowHunter

I would shoot both,---- I am that good. JK




seriously---I would take the first one.

jimpok61

I'd go for the ol' bugger. Then I'd say the deer hunters prayer. Thank you Lord for your great blessings. I'll be a good boy this year so if you can in anyway send that other fella my way next season I'll be very certain to be a real good boy. Amen!

ncbowhunter

If I saw two bucks like that in my area I'd probably fall out of the tree!

BigDaddy12t

I would have to say the 150 class buck. But I wouldnt be too picky, My biggest one to date is a 120 class 8 pointer, and that one was with a gun.[:'(]

Olink

How would you know how old either of them were? Ask to check their teeth before you shoot one?

Tribal

Well tough one. Depends on character of rack. I have been lucky enough to shoot some nice bucks. This year I shot what would have been a 18 pointer. Triple brow tines, mass over 6 inches at base and in between each g tine. Yes he was part moose. He will end up scoring lower than a 10 pointer I shot last year which was a 150 class net. He was a old boy on the down side.

But I would much rather harvest him than my 10 pointer just because his rack is so unique. Don't get me wrong I am very thankful for every harvest I get. But if similar I would take the larger rack.

Taureaunoir

I'll go for ??????????? 6points and up
Taureau noir