Is it ETHICAL(ha) to shoot does this late?
12-09-2008, 05:54 PM
#1
Nontypical Buck
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Allegany County Maryland
Posts: 1,977
Is it ETHICAL(ha) to shoot does this late?
I believe this has been beat to death ebfore but figured I would ask again! In reality would it be better to take a small buck this time of the year or a doe that possibly has two small bucks inside of her?? In most cases right now if we kill a doe, are we not killing 2-3 deer??
I am asking this question as if you had no choice and NEEDED meat for the freezer. I dont wanna hear that you would not shoot either, I wanna hear what you would rather do if you HAD too????
I am asking this question as if you had no choice and NEEDED meat for the freezer. I dont wanna hear that you would not shoot either, I wanna hear what you would rather do if you HAD too????
12-09-2008, 05:59 PM
#2
Dominant Buck
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location:
Posts: 21,043
RE: Is it ETHICAL(ha) to shoot does this late?
Do they (does) need taking whre you hunt?
If so....there is NEVER a bad time to take them. Let's say you took a doe in Sept. v. December. Didn't you kill those 2 potential buck fawns then, also?
I don't give a second thought as to what time of year I take them. In fact.....the earlier you take them....the more food is available for the others. But rest assured.....I'll shoot them all the way 'til our closer. NEVER a bad time to take a doe, here.
If so....there is NEVER a bad time to take them. Let's say you took a doe in Sept. v. December. Didn't you kill those 2 potential buck fawns then, also?
I don't give a second thought as to what time of year I take them. In fact.....the earlier you take them....the more food is available for the others. But rest assured.....I'll shoot them all the way 'til our closer. NEVER a bad time to take a doe, here.
12-09-2008, 06:02 PM
#3
Nontypical Buck
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Allegany County Maryland
Posts: 1,977
RE: Is it ETHICAL(ha) to shoot does this late?
ORIGINAL: GMMAT
Do they (does) need taking whre you hunt?
If so....there is NEVER a bad time to take them. Let's say you took a doe in Sept. v. December. Didn't you kill those 2 potential buck fawns then, also?
Do they (does) need taking whre you hunt?
If so....there is NEVER a bad time to take them. Let's say you took a doe in Sept. v. December. Didn't you kill those 2 potential buck fawns then, also?
You know I have never thought of it that way?? Thats a good way to look at it!!
12-09-2008, 06:13 PM
#4
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location:
Posts: 2,139
RE: Is it ETHICAL(ha) to shoot does this late?
ORIGINAL: WesternMdHardwoods
I believe this has been beat to death ebfore but figured I would ask again! In reality would it be better to take a small buck this time of the year or a doe that possibly has two small bucks inside of her?? In most cases right now if we kill a doe, are we not killing 2-3 deer??
I am asking this question as if you had no choice and NEEDED meat for the freezer. I dont wanna hear that you would not shoot either, I wanna hear what you would rather do if you HAD too????
I believe this has been beat to death ebfore but figured I would ask again! In reality would it be better to take a small buck this time of the year or a doe that possibly has two small bucks inside of her?? In most cases right now if we kill a doe, are we not killing 2-3 deer??
I am asking this question as if you had no choice and NEEDED meat for the freezer. I dont wanna hear that you would not shoot either, I wanna hear what you would rather do if you HAD too????
Whatever you do you will tick someone off. If you shoot a doe your killing 3 deer, if you kill a small buck the QDM people will want to hang you, if you kill a fawn ..... well, I'm not even going to go there. I've been there and it's a real ugly place!
I would shoot the doe.
12-09-2008, 06:20 PM
#6
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Stillwater OK
Posts: 2,944
RE: Is it ETHICAL(ha) to shoot does this late?
I have 2 more does tags left, and I will do all I can to fill those between now and Jan 15th. GMMAT said the same way I would have. No matter when you take a doe, that fawn won't be born.
12-09-2008, 06:29 PM
#7
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: SE Ohio
Posts: 2,531
RE: Is it ETHICAL(ha) to shoot does this late?
ORIGINAL: GMMAT
Do they (does) need taking whre you hunt?
If so....there is NEVER a bad time to take them. Let's say you took a doe in Sept. v. December. Didn't you kill those 2 potential buck fawns then, also?
I don't give a second thought as to what time of year I take them. In fact.....the earlier you take them....the more food is available for the others. But rest assured.....I'll shoot them all the way 'til our closer. NEVER a bad time to take a doe, here.
Do they (does) need taking whre you hunt?
If so....there is NEVER a bad time to take them. Let's say you took a doe in Sept. v. December. Didn't you kill those 2 potential buck fawns then, also?
I don't give a second thought as to what time of year I take them. In fact.....the earlier you take them....the more food is available for the others. But rest assured.....I'll shoot them all the way 'til our closer. NEVER a bad time to take a doe, here.
12-09-2008, 06:42 PM
#8
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Canadian Tx, currently Stillwater Ok.
Posts: 322
RE: Is it ETHICAL(ha) to shoot does this late?
Around here, I would definately shoot the doe. I havetaken 2 since the peak of the rutandif I dontget a buck before Jan 15 willtake 2 more if I can. Will definately try for at least one more.
12-09-2008, 06:43 PM
#9
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: West MI
Posts: 408
RE: Is it ETHICAL(ha) to shoot does this late?
I agree with Jeff. With an over population of deer in my area and poor sex ratios, ANYTIME during the season is a good time to take a doe. Everyone's area is different, but I don't think it's ever unethical to shoot a doe. It's either a good decision or bad decision based on the herd. But I'd never say unethical.