early in

From looking at the original 2 buck pics, even with different lighting and a slightly different angle, the throat patch on the one (left side)buck looks much wider than the other. Also, the G-2 on the buck on the leftcurves inward at more of an angle than the buck on the right

shrewbeer

how about showing the un-cropped pics so we can see the body

Double Creek

I think you have 2 deer, a 9pt and a 10pt. The two deer in THIS thread are the same. The other thread has 2 different deer, IMO.

TexasBowHunter

I think after looking over the two pic's from theearlier thread and then looking at the pic's from this threadwe have two different deer between all 4 pic's. IMO out of the 4 pic's 3 pictures are of the same deer, leaving the 10 point (left pic from old thread) to be the only one that is different. The other 3 pic's are of the same deer...IMO

GrayDawg

He was determined in the last thread to NOT be the same as the 10 pointer. We thought we only had one 9 point running around this area, then we took note of the 8/24 picture & what we thought were different throat patches.

This is why I ask for different people's opinions- as it may not be until the 57th person who replies who identifies something that everyone else missed.

For the record- in this little patch of wooded acreage, we have at least:

- one 10 point
- one 9 point
- three 8 points

Rob

finner

I would say yes also, on the right side g2 there is a little curve to it, and can see it on both pics.