peakrut

True but in my part of the country its either yuppie suburbinites, anti hunting, or a bad experience with hunters. First two go kind of hand in hand.

Deleted User

[Deleted by Admins]

James Vee

Call the game warden. The property owner may own the land, but he does not own the game on it. The state does. Have a good relationship with your wardens and this will never be a problem for you.

GMMAT

I wish it were that simple.....but it isn't. EVEN IF the GW wanted to....he has no rights (in some states) that trumps the landowners' (and rightfully so in my eyes).

I'm not picking on anyone....because this quoted sentiment is a popular one....

What bothers me (anda LOT of landowners) is......that the respect the deer is perceived due.....somehow trumps the respect the landowner is due.

Never have nor never will understand that.

SteveBNy

Everyone preseason scouts, practises, and does everything they need to be ready to hunt.

WHY is meeting with the neighboring landowners to discuss the possibility of retrival as important as any thing else you do to prepare?

You then know when setting up stands or sometimes whether or not to shoot what the consequences might be from your action.
I don't go without specific permission and do not allow others without prior permission and contact after the shot to go onto ours.
Been burned too many times by neighboring wandering stateland hunters and those who set on the line (woods on our side - open field on theirs - they are hunting and shooting onto our property. Don't want to play by the rules and respect us, you go to court if we catch you one foot over the line.

And there is no right to retrival in NYS - no officer of any kind can assist over the landowners objection.

Steve

jim1966

bowmanaj What regulation book are you reading??

Do Not Trespass

It is illegal to hunt, trap, chase or retrieve

game on private land without the consent of

the landowner or tenant. Always ask permission

before entering private property. A sample private

landowner permission form is found on page 50.

^^^^^^^^^^^^^ This is straight out of the Indiana hunting regulation book. It is illegal to go onto someone elses property POSTED OR NOT POSTED in Indiana.

James Vee

GMMAT; in Wisconsin it IS that simple. Babe should have had a better relationship with the warden.

(or he should have made a better shot)

kelleno

i watched that this morning too.

jakelogsdon

If there is a chance that your wounded animal could cross a property line. You being the hunter should have foreseen that possibility and requested permission from the neighboring land owner proir to the hunt. If the land owner will not grant you access, don't take a shot where and when there is a likely chance your animal could die in the no fly zone. Especially don't hunt on the property line like some people i know. Anyway stuff happens, but preparation is key. All you can do is try to avoid the issue the best way you can, and hope to make a clean fast kill every time.

Sylvan

I like the laws in NY. There is no right to enter someones land without permission posted or not. If you do you are tresspassing. Even a game warden can not come on your property for the purpose of pursuing someones wounded animal. A warden can enter private propertyoutside of what is called the curtilage only for the purpose of checking licenceses of hunters envolved in a hunt or if there is probable cause envovinga violation. The curtilage is the area of land occupied by a dwelling and its yard and outbuildings, actually enclosed or considered as enclosed. A warden needs a warrant to enter your curtilage just like any other cop. There are a couple of exceptions to allow for extreme situations like if a crime is in progress or to prevent loss of life or injury. I'm not sure about the specifics of the exceptions but finding somebody's deer certainly isn't one of them.

Imo, finding a wounded or downed deer is no reason to violate private property rights.