WHOSE BUCK IS IT??
10-08-2006, 05:46 PM
#31
Boone & Crockett
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Michigan/Ohio
Posts: 11,682
RE: WHOSE BUCK IS IT??
I think they should donate the deer meat, take the whole groups hunting privaleges away for a year. Make these guys the posters boys on "What not to do"!!
And What Rob said!
Just so you guys know, 2 years ago on Nov 14th I had 150 class 8 point walking by me at 5 yds, and I would not take the shot!! Last chance at the brute. The bow was back and pinon target, I just was not sure. My rule, if I have to think about it, I do not take the shot!!
I am glad the deer was killed, but please use better judgement next time, or get some new friends.
And What Rob said!
Just so you guys know, 2 years ago on Nov 14th I had 150 class 8 point walking by me at 5 yds, and I would not take the shot!! Last chance at the brute. The bow was back and pinon target, I just was not sure. My rule, if I have to think about it, I do not take the shot!!
I am glad the deer was killed, but please use better judgement next time, or get some new friends.
10-08-2006, 06:10 PM
#33
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: PA
Posts: 9,085
RE: WHOSE BUCK IS IT??
first id go shopping for new hunting buddys. then..id say second guy should tag it..claim it whatever. he killed it. i find it hard to believe that the first moron would ever find it.
first blood my foot...thats a good law to go by...but when someone shoots the tail off a BRUISER and it walks under your stand an hour later and they see you dragging it out youd be giving it up?? get real. over my dead body..sad thing is i think our game commision goes by first blood[&:] to me you gota have an open mind. sure someone 50yds down the ridge double lungs a deer and it runs to my spot and stops and i shoot it and had no idea and he could prove he shot it..its going home with him..even though i anchored it.
first blood my foot...thats a good law to go by...but when someone shoots the tail off a BRUISER and it walks under your stand an hour later and they see you dragging it out youd be giving it up?? get real. over my dead body..sad thing is i think our game commision goes by first blood[&:] to me you gota have an open mind. sure someone 50yds down the ridge double lungs a deer and it runs to my spot and stops and i shoot it and had no idea and he could prove he shot it..its going home with him..even though i anchored it.
10-08-2006, 08:32 PM
#35
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Ohio
Posts: 162
RE: WHOSE BUCK IS IT??
LOL at Fieldmouse 
My opinion would be killing shot should take the deer, and I agree with most of the folksfirst should not have shot to begin with, second only shot if he saw that the animal was wounded and trying to take it down to stop its suffering. Bad JooJoo there my friend.
My opinion would be killing shot should take the deer, and I agree with most of the folksfirst should not have shot to begin with, second only shot if he saw that the animal was wounded and trying to take it down to stop its suffering. Bad JooJoo there my friend.
10-09-2006, 01:36 AM
#38
Fork Horn
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: WESTERN NY / NORTHERN PA
Posts: 190
RE: WHOSE BUCK IS IT??
DITTO
ORIGINAL: goherd1111
First, I don't agree with shooting a deer on the run with a bow or firearm for that matter. However, The guy who killed it with the neck shot should claim the deer.
First, I don't agree with shooting a deer on the run with a bow or firearm for that matter. However, The guy who killed it with the neck shot should claim the deer.
10-09-2006, 03:54 AM
#39
Boone & Crockett
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location:
Posts: 11,472
RE: WHOSE BUCK IS IT??
we were putting on a deer drive during archery season
and i think you need to watch your choice of words... because i guarantee you when you get in that zone and a deer of that stature runs by you.. you wont just let it run by