View Poll Results: A poll
Voters: 131. You may not vote on this poll
Kill or Harvest?
09-27-2006, 04:02 AM
#21
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: El Dorado, Arkansas
Posts: 2,174
RE: Kill or Harvest?
Farmers harvest their crops......I kill deer !!! Always have -- Always will.
I make no apologies for my hunting ! God gave me the animals of the world to use, and if it is ok with God then it is ok with me. Because I answer to no man, but to our Heavenly Father.
God did not invent political correctness, man did.
BTW - If we, "the hunters", do not have a backbone and stand up for ourselves and what we believe in, then who will? If you, the people who hunt,can't say what you do ( kill ) honestly and without apologizing, then we have already lost " the fight ".
Good Hunting
God Bless
I make no apologies for my hunting ! God gave me the animals of the world to use, and if it is ok with God then it is ok with me. Because I answer to no man, but to our Heavenly Father.
God did not invent political correctness, man did.
BTW - If we, "the hunters", do not have a backbone and stand up for ourselves and what we believe in, then who will? If you, the people who hunt,can't say what you do ( kill ) honestly and without apologizing, then we have already lost " the fight ".
Good Hunting
God Bless
09-27-2006, 04:30 AM
#23
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: May 2006
Location: MA
Posts: 1,653
RE: Kill or Harvest?
Depends on who I'm talking to. If its a hunting bud I thumped, whacked, spiked or sumpin like that. If it is someone I don't know I usually say I gently pulled back the cellophane wrapper...>>>>>>Whack!!
09-27-2006, 06:26 AM
#24
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Upstate New York
Posts: 2,435
RE: Kill or Harvest?
Question: Why do many hunters seem to think that using the term "harvest" is appologetic or somehowan attempt toavoid the fact that hunters kill things? I and many other hunters use both terms where appropriate and appologize for neither the choice of words or the act they refer to. English is a rich language with lots of wordsavailable to be used to give differingnuancewhen communicating. Both "kill" and "harvest" are applicable terms in this discussion and I don't think anybody is dim enough to not realize that harvesting animals includes killing them. People are only fooling themselves if after killing a deer they think they didn'tharvest a natural resource. By the same token if after harvesting an animal you think you didn't kill it you've got real issues.
09-27-2006, 06:41 AM
#25
Dominant Buck
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location:
Posts: 21,043
RE: Kill or Harvest?
Go to the bedroom with your wife.
Take off all your clothes.....and go at it for an hour.
Tell each other what you did to one another.
-----------------------------------
Now......go tell your children what you did.
Did you use the same words?
Gentlemen.....That God that everyone answers to doesn't make laws that outlaw hunting. I'm only trying to make sure the tree-hugger that might overhear me doesn't take offense to what I'm saying. The hunter I'm talking to knows exactly what I'm saying, too. An animal dies when it's harvested. It is killed. Point taken.
Jeff
Take off all your clothes.....and go at it for an hour.
Tell each other what you did to one another.
-----------------------------------
Now......go tell your children what you did.
Did you use the same words?
Gentlemen.....That God that everyone answers to doesn't make laws that outlaw hunting. I'm only trying to make sure the tree-hugger that might overhear me doesn't take offense to what I'm saying. The hunter I'm talking to knows exactly what I'm saying, too. An animal dies when it's harvested. It is killed. Point taken.
Jeff
09-27-2006, 07:20 AM
#27
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location:
Posts: 6,006
RE: Kill or Harvest?
BDC I hear that one all the time.
My response is usually "Nope, but I killed a big one."
The reason I asked this question is put into perspective by several of the responses;
"It depends on who I'm talking to."
Those are the responses that make me think that the term harvest is replacing the word kill as a more politically correct way of saying things. People are doing it to protect others, namely the non-hunting/anti-hunting crowd.
I feel no reason to say harvest to protect anyone's feelings. I do what I do and I'm not ashamed of it, nor will I try to hide it or cover it up with a differentword.
My response is usually "Nope, but I killed a big one."
The reason I asked this question is put into perspective by several of the responses;
"It depends on who I'm talking to."
Those are the responses that make me think that the term harvest is replacing the word kill as a more politically correct way of saying things. People are doing it to protect others, namely the non-hunting/anti-hunting crowd.
I feel no reason to say harvest to protect anyone's feelings. I do what I do and I'm not ashamed of it, nor will I try to hide it or cover it up with a differentword.
09-27-2006, 07:34 AM
#28
Typical Buck
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: NH
Posts: 854
RE: Kill or Harvest?
My inlaws are big time anti's...when they ask how the hunting is going I usually say "I've taken one" or "I got a nice one". I don't use "kill" or "harvest" with them.
I didn't raise the deer, I didn't harvest it.
I didn't raise the deer, I didn't harvest it.
09-27-2006, 08:20 AM
#29
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Bremen, GA.
Posts: 2,091
RE: Kill or Harvest?
I have always sead "kill, took or shot" thats just what i am doing.
Afarmer uses "Harvest" thats just what he is doing.
If you talk to a few real farmers and ask what they wouldlike for you to do with all those deer eating there crops there awnser is kill them shoot them or take them.
I guess when a prisoner is put to death on death row the government should say We Harvested a prisioner today
I understand the reason someuse the wordharvest instead of kill its to keep from offending anyone that is watching these TV hunting shows or people that don`t hunt.
In the Websters dictionary the word KILL-says
1#To deprive of life,slay
2#To slaughter for food;Butcher
3#To destroy;put an end to
4#An animale killed as pray
5# Killed in the act of killing in hunting
Look it for yourself?
HARVEST-The act of of gathering in a crop ect..
[hr]
I`m Not trying to be a jerk or anything But tell it like it is.
Afarmer uses "Harvest" thats just what he is doing.
If you talk to a few real farmers and ask what they wouldlike for you to do with all those deer eating there crops there awnser is kill them shoot them or take them.
I guess when a prisoner is put to death on death row the government should say We Harvested a prisioner today
I understand the reason someuse the wordharvest instead of kill its to keep from offending anyone that is watching these TV hunting shows or people that don`t hunt.
In the Websters dictionary the word KILL-says
1#To deprive of life,slay
2#To slaughter for food;Butcher
3#To destroy;put an end to
4#An animale killed as pray
5# Killed in the act of killing in hunting
Look it for yourself?
HARVEST-The act of of gathering in a crop ect..
[hr]
I`m Not trying to be a jerk or anything But tell it like it is.
09-27-2006, 08:50 AM
#30
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Almost Heaven. Boone Co. WV
Posts: 1,003
RE: Kill or Harvest?
"harvest" in regards to hunting is just a way to soften the reality that animals die when a hunt is successful. The TV hunters I think are responsible for the use more than anyone else.
I always say "Kill" not to be imflamatory, it's just what I have always said.
I always say "Kill" not to be imflamatory, it's just what I have always said.