js2397

What do you think these deer would score and would you shoot them?

flyfishpj

Idon't know if I would take the top, but the bottom is definately a shooter, and probably in his prime.

early in

I would happily take either one of those bucks. Great pics!

flyfishpj

Is that a drop tine or peeling velvet on the bottom?

r33h

I like them both! good luck!

wis_bow_huntr

Id take the botom one for sure just because he has a kicker.

OUTLAWCREWREDMAN

They look maybe 3 to 4 years old, i would let them walk another year.

HuntingEd

the top would be bout 115-125, the second will probably be around 140.Thats my guess. Id let the top go and shoot the bottom. Looks like hes startin to loose his velvet. Its just a matter of time fellas!! good luck w/ him.

Trembow

They would both taste very good to me

The top one would score teryaki and the bottom one hickory smoked.

superstrutter

The first one 115 to 120. The second one in the 130's. They are both nice bucks. I guess it depends where you are hunting. If I saw either of these on my place in north La. I wouldn't hesitate to shoot. Up north they may be average bucks. It doesn't really matter what everyone else thinks. If they are good enough for you then try and take them. The second one would go on my wall any day.