asianhunter

they are both good and inexpensive broaadheads but which one is better?

121553

Either or, its just a mater of preference. I use 125 thunderheads cause I know they work, butmuzzy does too as they would be my next choice.
Bobby

kevin1

I use Thunderheads , nothing against the Muzzys I just like the design of the Thunderhead better .

mrfritz44

I've used both and each has their qualities.

Pros: Thunderheads have a wide cut andare surgically sharp out of the package. Muzzys generally fly better (smaller diameter) and are made to withstand harder hits on bone.
Cons: Thunderheads are a tad heavier than advertised and tend to fly lower than field tips unless the bow is tuned for them. Muzzy's are comparatively duller out of the box than THeads andthe chisel point tends to rust throughout the season.

My personal preference is for Thunderheads only because I've made bad hits on deer with them before, but the blood trail was huge and I was able to recover the deer. I'd say it's a toss-up. The fact that they sit next to each other on the Walmart shelf should make your choice even tougher!

jsasker

I have shot both and am now using muzzy for the fourth year in a row.Muzzy is not as sharp but is way more durable--fact.

rybohunter

You can't go wrong with either. Personally I shoot T-heads. They've held up hitting bone and give me good blood trails. It's a no lose situation between the 2.

mainehunt

Muzzy all the way, I think they're tougher than the T-heads.

I've never had a Muzzy rust yet.

mrfritz44

It doesn't rain in Maine?

ijimmy

I like muzzys better because of blade retention . The thunderheads are sharp but I dont like the way the blades are held

Bulzeye

I'm not familiar with the Muzzys you mentioned, but the T-heads are fine and plenty tough. A few years ago I hit a small buck a bit high and buried one in his spine. It was stuck in all the way to the rear of the blades. It was in fine shape after the hit. The only thing that prevented me from continuing to use it was that the butcher went after it with a pair of pliers instead of a saw, so it got pretty bent.

I'll buy more expensive ones someday when these wear out, but until then, I have no problem trusting the T-heads.