davidmil

Hmmmmmm......here we go again. Believe I've heard this one before.

MOTOWNHONKEY

Washington, you can brown nose ole jack all you want, that,s your fettish. When he comes on here telling people how they can hunt or should hunt,there are going to be replies. Who cares if he didn,t name names, people who made those post on the last topic knew who he was talking about. I don,t hunt over bait or behind high fences, but if I wanted to and it was legal in my state I would do it.

jsasker

Sooooooo now we are all gonna sit here and judge JACK?Jack,i think you'll add alot of excitement to this forum--you sure know what buttons to push.You don't know anyone that goes by the handle c903 do you?[8D]

Arthur P

I notice that treestands and mechanical releases weren't mentioned in Jack's tirade. So, obviously, there is a level of "cheating" he's comfortable with.

Washington Hunter

It isn't a matter of brown nosing anyone, Motown. There has been a lot of this crap going on in here lately and it's getting old - fast. It seems like the same thing happens every year right around this time. If you're not mature enough to just let him whine about what he thinks is right and what he thinks is wrong without having to try and take him down a peg or two, then you've got a lot of growing up to do.

MOTOWNHONKEY

Hmmm, I guess your right. It does take two to tango!! It just sounded more like an attack on fellow hunters to me than an opinion. Sorry

atlasman

I don't view treestands or releases as cheating at all. If you look at things that way then anything other then your bare hands is cheating.........and I guess you would have to be naked as well.

Paul L Mohr

The problem is where do you draw the line? When is it ethical, when is it cheating? By cheating I would assume you mean poaching, and there are laws for that. If you don't agree with them then try to get them changed. I agree with some of the others, who decided you were the one that chooses what is ethical or cheating for someone else? Oh, you did I guess, I certainly didn't bestow that burdon on you.

And I think everyones version of ethical is different. To me being ethical is about how you treat the animal. Like doing what it takes to insure that the animal suffers the least. Like not taking high percentage shots like too long of a distance or shooting at moving game. A gun hunter could argue that bow hunting is not ethical becuase it is not as effective. And a compound hunter could argue that traditional shooters are unethical because you have less power and don't use sights and stuff. Making it much easier to wound an animal. You can take this line of thinking in any direction you want really. There will always be someone that thinks the other is wrong.

I highly doubt the people doing these things are coming on here asking these questions or looking for sympathy or forgiveness . If they thought what they were doing was wrong they would not do it. And they certainly wouldn't come here and let everyone one know if they were doing something they thought was wrong. While I don't care much for some of the things you mentioned like hunting off a buss or shooting penned animals I don't consider it cheating or unethical. It's not much different than raising pigs and cattle and killing one to slaughter. I have never met anyone that did this or took a guided hunt and lied about how they obtained the animal. If they were happy with what they did, then more power to them I guess. If you don't want to do that, then don't.

I hunt from a treestand and bait, because it is legal where I live and I will do what ever is legal to harvest deer. I didn't pay for deer tags to go nature watching, I could do that for free. And the state doesn't issue tags so you don't shoot deer. Why do you think the laws in some places get easier? Because we are not harvesting enough deer. I could argue that it's because of trophy hunters, but I don't. I don't think a few handfulls of corn on the edge of a 200 acre corn field is going to exactly make the deer flock to my stand. Baiting is not that effective. I use it to get the deer to stop so I can make a clean shot on a relaxed animal. If you don't agree with that then I don't think you are a very ethical hunter either.

I gun hunt as well, so I guess that makes me evil and my opinion probably doesn't even count.

Dan, I agree with you, personal attacks and just being mean to someone is not a great thing. However he posted this thread looking for these sort of responses so I wouldn't get too upset when it actually happens.

Paul

datamax

Jack RyanPlease descibe how you hunt each fall, what you hunt with, what your goals are etc etc and I'll be more than happy to rip you apart for it.

Deal ?

Justin

As the resident Evil Administrator Guy, I think I need to step in here and say "No you won't".

This thread is walking the line right now, so let's start playing nice.