45 or 50??
#1
Nontypical Buck
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Rivesville, WV
Posts: 3,192
45 or 50??
I have been kicking around a purchase of a Green Mountain LRH barel for a nice Renegade I have sitting in the safe. I was all set on getting a 50 caliber, but I started doing a little more shopping. And it looks like they also make that barrel in a 1in28"-45 caliber barrel. I thought that was intriguing. I have a few 45 caliber molds. I also have a .451 mold for my WhitWorth rifle(the round bullet-not the hexagonal). I am starting to lean toward the 45 caliber. What do you guys think?? Anybody have one in 45 caliber?? If so what is the bore?? .450??
I also noticed they have one in Stainless. Is SS a little too funky looking on a traditional rifle like the Renegade?? Thanks, Tom.
I also noticed they have one in Stainless. Is SS a little too funky looking on a traditional rifle like the Renegade?? Thanks, Tom.
#2
Well I own them in both stainless steel and in the blued version. Actually in my personal opinion I like the looks of the stainless steel barrel. It reminds of the kit when I assembled it and before I browned the barrel of the original renegade it is on.
I was shooting the .45 caliber yesterday. Great shooting rifle. 85 grains of Goex 3f and a 180 grain Gold Dot and it was making a hole at 50 yards. Even the 200 grain Hornady XTP did real well. I do not know how hard I can push that bullet before it falls apart. I want to try some of the Lehigh bullets out of it.
I am not sure what the dimension of the bore is as I never slugged it. But the standard .45 caliber sabot and a 10mm bullet is a nice snug fitting load.
I have scopes mounted on the Stainless Steel models and no scopes on the blued models.
There is the .50 after a hard day on the range. They clean up like a dream by the way.
I was shooting the .45 caliber yesterday. Great shooting rifle. 85 grains of Goex 3f and a 180 grain Gold Dot and it was making a hole at 50 yards. Even the 200 grain Hornady XTP did real well. I do not know how hard I can push that bullet before it falls apart. I want to try some of the Lehigh bullets out of it.
I am not sure what the dimension of the bore is as I never slugged it. But the standard .45 caliber sabot and a 10mm bullet is a nice snug fitting load.
I have scopes mounted on the Stainless Steel models and no scopes on the blued models.
There is the .50 after a hard day on the range. They clean up like a dream by the way.
#3
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 1,184
I have both as well. For all around hunting I think that the 50 is a better choice. The two 45's I have are both different. 1 has a 1-28 twist .451 and the other is a 1-18 twist .458. The max length for the 1-28 is about .875 or less. There is not many bullets that fall into that catagory but there are some options. Mine also tend to like lead that is a pinch harder than pure. I like my 45's but only death will part me from my 50. Ron
#5
HEAD0001
Tom, i have both Blued and stainless in my Rene stocks. I really do like the stainless... blue is nice, but stainless well it's set it apart.... course I can not bring myself to do the Semisane or Cayugad thing - they remain un-scoped...
Now days the Hawken stock is gone and evertything is in a Renegade stock... I am just a plain old guy so I like the plain old Renegade...
45 or 50 - ifn you have a 50 might as well get a 45... I have often thought about just that thing for Rondie shoots... But a fast twist 45 would make an excellent deer hunter....
Tom, i have both Blued and stainless in my Rene stocks. I really do like the stainless... blue is nice, but stainless well it's set it apart.... course I can not bring myself to do the Semisane or Cayugad thing - they remain un-scoped...
Now days the Hawken stock is gone and evertything is in a Renegade stock... I am just a plain old guy so I like the plain old Renegade...
45 or 50 - ifn you have a 50 might as well get a 45... I have often thought about just that thing for Rondie shoots... But a fast twist 45 would make an excellent deer hunter....
#6
Well I don't have any with a silver finish, and I don't spend much on scopes. This $39.00 scope might not sound like much, but so far I have not been able to shake it apart, and the clarity of the glass is excellent. It is a Simmon Pro Diamond 4x32mm.
As far as whether it looks right... I really don't care. I am not into looks as much as I am function.
#8
While I prefer the 40/200 grain - probably the best option is the 40/185DOA. It does not have to driven as hard from a 1/28 twist. Normal 90-100 grains loads will push it along just fine.