Some questions from the other end of the spectrum
#1
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Iowa
Posts: 779
Some questions from the other end of the spectrum
Has anyone shot the savage smokeless muzzleloader? Are their any smokeless muzzleloaders other than savages? Do some states not allow smokeless muzzleloaders to be used during muzzleloader season? Or are their any other special regulations on them?
#3
RE: Some questions from the other end of the spectrum
The Savage muzzleloader is not the only one. There are some other models out there, but they tend to be expensive. As for regulations, be sure and check the area you want to hunt, and the laws of that State as some do not allow "smokeless powder." Also some do not allow certain ignition systems on muzzleloaders.
From all I have read, the Savage is a great muzzleloader. They are very well made, accurate, and well tested. While some like to compare the Savage to a center fire, I can assure you it is a muzzleloader. It loads likeone, the only difference is the brand of powder. If we judge a rifle solely on powder, could not a true black powder shooter then claim that for example, a Winchester Apex is not a true muzzleloader because the shooters uses Triple Se7en, or Black Mag3.
From all I have read, the Savage is a great muzzleloader. They are very well made, accurate, and well tested. While some like to compare the Savage to a center fire, I can assure you it is a muzzleloader. It loads likeone, the only difference is the brand of powder. If we judge a rifle solely on powder, could not a true black powder shooter then claim that for example, a Winchester Apex is not a true muzzleloader because the shooters uses Triple Se7en, or Black Mag3.
#4
RE: Some questions from the other end of the spectrum
#5
Boone & Crockett
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: River Ridge, LA (Suburb of New Orleans)
Posts: 10,918
RE: Some questions from the other end of the spectrum
Looked at the Bad Bull site. Gotta laugh. How many good quality and fun muzzleloaders could you buy for $3,200? Gotta cry. I don't have that kind of dough...[&o]
#6
RE: Some questions from the other end of the spectrum
Speciality companies are just that. They cater to a small market share and rely on quality and the promise of a better product to get clients. If money was not the question, it would be fine to have such a rifle. But for now, I'd rather play with a large selection of other rifles then one rifle...
#7
RE: Some questions from the other end of the spectrum
ORIGINAL: QTompkins2005
Has anyone shot the savage smokeless muzzleloader? Are their any smokeless muzzleloaders other than savages? Do some states not allow smokeless muzzleloaders to be used during muzzleloader season? Or are their any other special regulations on them?
Has anyone shot the savage smokeless muzzleloader? Are their any smokeless muzzleloaders other than savages? Do some states not allow smokeless muzzleloaders to be used during muzzleloader season? Or are their any other special regulations on them?
There are states which don't permit smokeless powder, but the Savage can be used with BP or a BP substitute as well as smokeless. For example, Colorado doesn't permit sabots, so the Savage could not be used there with smokeless, since smokeless requires the use of a sabot......
#9
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location:
Posts: 3,246
RE: Some questions from the other end of the spectrum
ORIGINAL: QTompkins2005
Has anyone shot the savage smokeless muzzleloader? Are their any smokeless muzzleloaders other than savages? Do some states not allow smokeless muzzleloaders to be used during muzzleloader season? Or are their any other special regulations on them?
Has anyone shot the savage smokeless muzzleloader? Are their any smokeless muzzleloaders other than savages? Do some states not allow smokeless muzzleloaders to be used during muzzleloader season? Or are their any other special regulations on them?
http://www.the-gleasons.com/this_is_my_savage_10_ml_page.htm
Yes, like Bad Bull. Do some states not allow them? Yes, but some do. I hunt in Va and NY, and they both do now or it was clarified to allow smokeless powder. Special regulations on them? Varies by state. Some consider them a ML, some don't. I bought mine because it is more accurate and shoots flatter. It is NOT a CF rifle, you don't use cases, you use 209 shot shell primers, the same as an inline. Only difference is the Savage shoots higher pressure smokeless powder and the other MLs shoot BP substitute, which makes smoke, but is little difference except power. For a comparison of Smokeless vs BP see this:
http://www.randywakeman.com/ballltd120.htm
I intend to hunt both ML and rifle season with the Smokeless Savage. It is a great rifle for $550. I like mine, very accurate, and very little recoil with 44g of 5744 using 300g bullets. A really great board for Savage facts is:
http://dougva.proboards34.com/index.cgi?board=Savage
There are a lot of guys on that board who know a lot more about them than I do. Regards, Chap Gleason
#10
Join Date: Jun 2007
Posts: 3
RE: Some questions from the other end of the spectrum
In addition to the advantages pointed out by Chap Gleason, the other advantages of the Savage MLII are:1) less cleaning, both while shooting and after shooting. Most shoot better without cleaning between shots. No need to clean after a day of hunting unless the bore got wet. 2) No need to shoot or unload after a day of hunting-just remove the primer. Just don't bring the weapon in from the cold so that condensation can occur. 3) No cloud of smoke to obscure the reaction of the game animal to the shot. 4) This gun is a tack-driver when you find the right load-MOA or less.